Your guide to finding the best tasting dog food for finicky dogs, including in-depth responses to reader questions like:
- What to feed a finicky dog?
- How to get a finicky dog to eat?
- Best Dog Food For Finicky Eaters
- Best Dog Food For Finicky Small Dogs
- For Extra Finicky Eaters…
Even against my own better judgment, I gave in and offered her table food one night after dinner.
Would you believe she turned her nose up at that too?!
Yes, having a finicky dog can be a strain on the nerves, for so many reasons, so we wanted to offer you a few bits of information that has worked for us and finicky Fidos the world over.
Hopefully, it will help you too! Because we all just want what’s best for our fur babies, amirite?
What To Feed A Finicky Dog
If you’re anything like I was, you’ll be tempted to give your dog food straight from the table. I mean, isn’t that what all dogs want?
They stare, beg, and do all kinds of crazy things just for a bite of what you’re eating, but is that really the best idea?
It’s really not a good idea to feed your dog table scraps.
If you want the REAL story on table scraps…check out our in-depth guide, where we tell you about the safety of 200+ human foods for your dog(s).
For one thing, some of the foods we dearly love can be very harmful to our fur babies. Onions are one of these, and any food prepared with them is bad for your dog.
Healthy Paws Pet Insurance covers everything that matters including injuries, illnesses, genetic conditions, and emergency care. As part of your employee benefits program, you'll receive a special lifetime discount of up to 15%.
Learn more by getting a free quote and let Healthy Paws pay your vet bills while you care for your pet.
Oily foods or foods that contain a lot of fat can cause big time problems for dogs too, like vomiting and diarrhea or even pancreatitis.
Finally, feeding your dog table scraps can cause your dog to completely refuse dry dog food in the future. Once they think they can get their way by refusing that, they will continue to work that angle.
Believe you me!
And besides, slipping that piece of ham under the table will also lead to begging and other unwanted behaviors.
You can always mix the wet and dry, which makes him think he’s getting something completely new.
If all else fails, you can try making your very own dog food from scratch, right in your own kitchen.
You didn’t know this was possible?
It sure is, and you can try some of these great raw dog food recipes and tips to get you started.
How To Get A Finicky Dog To Eat
If you’re planning to make sure your dog gets accustomed to and eats the same food day in and day out, there are a few ways you can accomplish this:
1. You can do this by setting your dog’s food out for thirty minutes at mealtime.
If it remains uneaten, take it away.
Offer it again at the next mealtime, again for thirty minutes.
After a while, he will eat when the food is set out because he’s hungry and figured your game out.
It can be hard, but if your dog is incredibly finicky, it will be worth it.
2. Another thing you can try for your finicky eater is to switch to a higher quality dog food.
This is especially the case if you happen to be feeding your dog something like a generic brand name from your local department store.
Many foods like this simply don’t appeal to your dog’s taste buds and some dogs just won’t eat what they don’t like.
Best Dog Food For Finicky Eaters
Wellness CORE Natural Grain Free
One of the most trusted names among dog owners is Wellness CORE.
This recipe, Wellness CORE Natural Grain Free, is sure to please even the most finicky of eaters
With delicious flavors like:
- Ocean Whitefish, Herring & Salmon
- Original Turkey & Chicken,
- Wild Game Duck, Turkey, Boar & Rabbit
…your dog will have a hard time saying no to this dog food!
Not only does it taste great for your fur baby, it’s also full of nutrition that focuses on protein, without all the grains that could cause potential health problems.
We’ve found that some dogs, who normally won’t even think about eating dry dog food, actually prefer this Wellness CORE formula.
One dog owner even reported that her finicky eater immediately took to this dog food, with no prompting at all.
Knowing how hard it is to get some of these dogs to eat, I’d say that’s something worth checking into.
Best Dog Food For Finicky Small Dogs
Small dogs are notorious for thinking they are ten feet tall and bullet proof!
They don’t like to share their toys, their owners, or their food.
(That is, when they will eat it.)
Because small dogs are also notorious for being finicky eaters.
Blue Protection Small Breed Formula
That’s why we’re going to add BLUE Protection Small Breed Formula to our list today.
It’s another highly trusted name in the dog food market, with some dog owners swearing by it.
This formula boasts the True Blue Promise that says it is formulated with the finest natural ingredients.
Dogs love the flavor and you’ll love the face that it includes healthy whole grains, veggies, fruits and all the essential nutrition your small dog could possibly need.
One Pomeranian parent said that her dog would sometimes go as long as two days without eating, simply due to his finicky nature.
However, once she switched to BLUE, her dog never misses a meal and actually comes running when she asks, “Are you hungry?”
We have to agree that this is definite proof that the flavor is enticing.
For Extra Finicky Eaters…
If you’ve already tried these and several other dry dog foods, we suggest mixing your dry dog food with a bit of wet food.
This often does the trick when nothing else will and we have found that Cesar Classics is one of the best to use.
You get amazing flavors like:
- Roasted Chicken
- Grilled Chicken
- Chicken & Veal
- Chicken & Liver
- Duck and Turkey
…that will really make your finicky eater take a second look for sure.
By the way…
Cesar guarantees even the fussiest eater will be pleased with the flavor, or your money back!
You literally have nothing to lose!
Dog owners all agree that Cesar works great for finicky eaters, with one telling about how her picky pup now empties her bowl faster than she ever has, and another saying that her dog will not pass up dry food that is mixed with Cesar’s.
We hope that after reading this, you will no longer have a finicky eater!
While there are lots of things that might bother us when it comes to our dogs, nothing is more worrisome than a dog that won’t eat.
However, with these tips, you should have a satisfied pet from now on.
Do you have a finicky eater that will only eat a certain kind of dog food?
Or a tip on how you got your finicky eater to eat regular meals again?
If so, please share it with us here.
We would love to hear about it and we’re sure our other readers would benefit from it as well!